When a top rep resigns, most founders start the search for a replacement the same week. That is understandable. It is also often a mistake.
If you do not know why they left, the next hire is likely to leave for the same reason.
These are the reasons we hear most often when talking to sales candidates who are open to a move, and what you can fix before you hire again.
1. The comp plan changed
Nothing makes a strong rep look elsewhere faster than a comp plan that changes mid-year. A higher quota, a lower rate, a new cap on earnings or a clawback clause all send the same message: the more you earn, the more we will take.
Top performers notice first, because they have the most to lose.
What to fix:
Set plans annually and stick to them.
Explain any change in person, with the reasoning, before it is in writing.
Never cap earnings for over-performance. Accelerators above 100% keep your best people.
Pay commission on time, every time.
2. The territory was taken away
A rep spends two years building relationships in a territory. Then the company hires a new AE, splits the patch and hands over half the accounts. The rep's pipeline drops overnight.
Territory changes are sometimes necessary as a company grows. Handled badly, they push out the people who built the territory in the first place.
What to fix:
Talk to the rep before the decision is final, not after.
Protect deals already in progress.
Offer something in return: named accounts, a bigger target segment, a step into leadership.
3. The quota stopped being achievable
When most of the team misses target, the problem is the quota, not the team. Strong reps know their market. If they can see the number is not reachable, they leave for a company where it is.
What to fix:
Track the percentage of reps hitting quota each quarter.
Base quotas on real pipeline and conversion data, not a board target divided by headcount.
Be honest in interviews about attainment. Candidates will ask.
4. The manager
Reps join companies and leave managers. A new sales leader who micromanages, changes the process every month or takes credit for deals will lose the best people first.
What to fix:
Ask departing reps about their manager directly, and listen to the answer.
Promote managers for leadership ability, not just because they were the top seller.
Run skip-level one-to-ones so problems surface before resignations.
5. No path to progress
Ambitious reps want to know what comes next. Senior AE, team lead, a bigger segment, a move into enterprise. If nobody has talked to them about it, a recruiter will.
What to fix:
Map out the next two steps for every rep.
Make promotion criteria clear and written down.
Promote from within where you can. It tells the whole team there is a path.
6. The product or market stalled
Sometimes the reason is outside the sales team. A product that has not shipped a meaningful update, a market that has gone quiet or a funding round that has not landed. Reps feel it in their pipeline before anyone else.
What to fix:
Share the roadmap and the company's position honestly.
Bring sales into product conversations.
If times are hard, say so. Silence makes good people assume the worst.
Before you rehire
Before you start a search to replace a rep who has left, answer four questions:
Why did they really leave? Ask in the exit conversation. Ask again a month later, when they have nothing to lose by being honest.
Is the same problem still there? If so, fix it first.
Is the role still the same? The company may have moved on since they were hired. Update the brief. Our guide to defining the sales role before you hire takes about an hour.
Who else is at risk? If one strong rep left for a reason, others may be thinking the same.
Then check your pay against the market. Our Sales and Marketing Salary Guide Ireland 2026 gives OTE ranges and typical base to variable splits for every GTM role.
Hire for the long term
The cost of losing a strong rep goes far beyond the recruitment fee. You lose their pipeline, their customer relationships and the months it takes a replacement to ramp.
The best defence is hiring people who fit the role as it is, being honest about the quota and the plan, and managing them well once they arrive.
Building or rebuilding a sales team? Our Embedded Recruitment and Recruitment as a Service models give you a recruiter who knows your team, your market and why people stay. Book a discovery call to talk it through.
The Recruiter is Ireland's specialist GTM and SaaS recruitment agency. We partner with VC-backed SaaS companies from Pre-Seed to Series C across Ireland and EMEA. Employment Agency Licence EA 4551.